Share bike commute: only 62% success

Geographers have long investigated commuting and transportation. While that isn’t my academic speciality, every commuter in the world probably has some comments and reflections on the “geographies of mobility” (to use current jargon).  Here are my reflections on the city of Lausanne’s shared-bike program, initially sponsored by the two universities EPFL and UNIL.

Lausanne’s bicycle sharing system is operated by PubliBike, owned by the Swiss Federal Railways (SBB/CFF), Postbus, and Rent-a-Bike.  The Lausanne network includes some 24 stations, with most (10) concentrated on the university campuses.  After registering, and a small annual fee (free for students), one uses an ID card to release the bikes from the station, and the first 30 minutes (90 for campus members) are free.

Publibike share bike photo from publibike.ch website

Publibike share bike photo from publibike.ch website

I tried using PubliBike as one part of my daily commute, filling in the 2 km gap between Renens Gare (on the main train line) and the Géopolis building of the University of Lausanne.  For six months (Jan. 1 to July 1, 2016), I kept records on my success in using this service.  The results (full table below), based on 130 different trip attempts, aren’t very encouraging.  Things went smoothly less than two-thirds of the time (62%). An additional one out of ten trips (11%) I succeeded in getting from point A to B but with some issues along the way.

But that leaves more than a quarter of my trips (28%) as failures.  Generally this meant I wasn’t able to access a bicycle – either there were none available at the station, or the station wouldn’t release the bikes present. The indicator lights beeped red instead of flashing green.

January to March were more successful than April to June, with 16 percent “fails” in the winter versus 35 percent in the spring.  PubliBike had a number of technical difficulties with the electronics of the stations in May (and offered subscribers 4 additional months for free).  This also explains some of the difficulties in getting bicycles: some times I had to try three, five, or even eight bikes before the posts would “beep green” and release a bike.

The good news is that the technical condition of the bikes was generally good.  And compared with last year (when I didn’t keep records), the supply of bicycles at Renens-Gare in the morning rush-hour was better.  And while I usually just zip back and forth between Géopolis and Renens-Gare, the PubliBike system allowed for some pleasureful alternative commutes, along the lake from Morges or Ouchy to campus.

Luckily, when I wasn’t able to access a bike, there are plenty of alternative options between Renens Gare and Géopolis: the light rail M1, the bus 31, or walking 15-20 minutes.  But my conclusion is that I’ll be looking into a folding bicycle (here’s Simon Batterbury’s excellent advice on Brompton vs. Birdy).

The data on my six month test of Publibike share bikes in Lausanne

The data on my six month test of Publibike share bikes in Lausanne

Advertisements

5 Responses to Share bike commute: only 62% success

  1. nippo says:

    This is a great documentation. As I occasionally use this system, I have 2 questions –

    1. Would you have gone for a personal folding bike if the system worked with 100% efficiency/reliability? (quality of bikes and other issues remaining…. just that you get a bike every time you want it)

    2. Did it effect your mood/state-of-mind when you didn’t get a bike? (i.e. did you get annoyed or angry) (e.g. If you decided to walk, then you walk anyways….as opposed to you decided to take a bike, but end up walking!!!)

    • Hi Nipesh, Good questions. If the system was 100%, I would have just continued to use it… and no, I got used to it not working and was always ready to walk (or on the way home I always left a 5-10 minute margin…). Best, c

  2. Nice to know that some professors go to the office a lot! For that very short commute, almost any folder would do – the Birdy is of course the best (and is continental European not a Brexit design!)

  3. Two pieces of mail from PubliBike today.

    One via the post, thanking me for my blog and giving me a year’s extension to my subscription. Now that is some fast customer service! Thank you very much indeed!

    And the other one via email: their system seemed to have totally crashed due to a technological problem linked to the 3G network. Disappointing! Here’s the email:

    “Unfortunately, at the moment it is not possible to borrow a bike at most PubliBike stations. This is due because sometimes there is no connection to the Salt network because it has braked down.

    We do everything in our power to solve this issue as quickly as possible. Once everything is working again, we will notify you.

    Thank you for your understanding.

    Kind regards,
    The PubliBike team”

  4. Update: I said I’d get a folding bike. Instead I settled for an alternate, much cheaper strategy that avoids lugging 10kg into the crowded train and keeping an eye on it: I got a second-hand bicycle that I keep at the train station (thanks to Arturo at my local bike shop http://www.bikespot.ch/).

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: